If you've been waiting to roll Horde on a PvP ruleset, there is no sign of a short-term unlock. On episode 7 of the official WoW: Forever podcast, posted in the early hours of November 13 Beijing time, developer Josh Greenfield (Aggrend) addressed the faction lock on character creation: limits have been tightened, and players who haven't made a Horde character should, in his words, "start making other arrangements at this point."
Wowhead's same-day report reads the remark as a sign the lock will hold for a while, and Massively Overpowered's follow-up — posted in the early hours of November 15, Beijing time, and linking straight to Wowhead's story — reaches the same call: the locks are not letting up any time soon. Both stories describe the same episode; the exact wording in this article follows Wowhead's transcription.
How Lopsided Is Too Lopsided: A Number, No Formula
Per Wowhead's account, Greenfield gave one new number: Blizzard typically allows a 10% delta in faction balance during launch, and that cap has now been reached. What the 10% actually measures — the raw gap between the two factions or some other yardstick — and which region hit the cap, the report does not say, and Blizzard has not published a formula.
It lines up on paper with community manager Kaivax's November 10 forum post, which put the most imbalanced region at roughly a 55/45 split, region-wide — a 10-point gap. Whether the two figures share the same yardstick, Blizzard has not said. That post also fixed the directions: for now NA PvP gates Horde, EU RP-PvP gates Alliance, creating on the crowded side keeps getting harder, and the restriction may flip to the other side later.
The Trial-Account Rumor Got a Direct Denial
One explanation made the rounds in the replies to that November 10 post: players were using trial accounts or level 1 characters to skew the balance and free up Horde slots. Greenfield dismissed it outright — by his account those accounts have no impact on the balance, and that is not how the system works. How population is actually counted — bank alts, parked characters — still has no official answer.
Same Episode: Scarlet Enclave Will Return, No Timetable
The episode also carried one piece of news unrelated to character creation: Greenfield said the Season of Discovery exclusive raid Scarlet Enclave and the Ashbringer storyline will return in Forever eventually — it may take a while, and there is no timetable.
What You Can Do Now
- Set on PvP but without a Horde character: let the character-create screen be the judge and try before you commit — NA PvP and EU RP-PvP gate different factions, so don't borrow another region's situation as your answer.
- Blocked from joining friends on one faction: switching rulesets or switching sides remain the two routes the blue post offered; no new alternatives have been announced.
- Think the official numbers don't match your server: post your server, time window and zone in Kaivax's thread — it passed 200 replies on November 10 alone, and it remains the most direct path to a more precise official answer.
- The timetable for lifting the lock, the formula behind the 10%, and the list of adjusted zones all lack an official source; when the next announcement or podcast episode lands, we'll check it against this article.