A player posted on the US official forums on November 16: since Judgement became a ranged attack, its crits no longer trigger Vengeance, and the poster asks Blizzard to fix that or revert the change outright. As of November 18 there is no reply from Blizzard, and the November 16 hotfix batch carries no related fix.

The official wording says Judgement crits should build Vengeance

The report only becomes legible next to Blizzard's own design text. The November 3 pre-launch development notes finalized Vengeance: stack cap back to 5 (was 3), and it now requires Seal of Command (previously Sanctified Judgement). The trigger wording is older: the September 24 changelog states that Vengeance activates off non-periodic critical strikes. A Judgement hit is not periodic damage — under that wording a Judgement crit should build Vengeance stacks, and whether Judgement counts as melee or ranged was never supposed to matter.

The ranged reclassification was Blizzard's own change, in two steps: the November 11 hotfix batch made Judgement a Ranged Attack, removing it from melee item and effect procs and switching it to the paladin's Ranged Hit chance; the November 13 batch then restored Judgement of Command specifically to melee resolution with its on-hit effects, while the developers' note drew the line — all other judgements continue to be considered Ranged attacks in WoW: Forever. This site covered both batches and the Vengeance redesign separately (the Nov 11 hotfix piece, the Nov 13 hotfix piece, and the Protection changes piece).

The report itself: one post, no second case, no response

The report leaves its scope unstated, and that is its biggest gap: the poster never says which seal was active. Since November 13, Judgement of Command resolves as a melee attack; the other seals' judgements are ranged by the official note. Whether the break is on the melee chain or the ranged chain, and whether the reclassification caused it at all, the post cannot answer — and this site has no client data and no in-game testing to fill that in. Beyond the original post there is only one reply, another player venting about the class in general; no second specific report of the interaction has appeared.

Verify it yourself in two minutes, then decide whether to reply

Turn on Seal of Command (the prerequisite talent for Vengeance), land a crit Judgement on a training dummy, and watch whether the stacks move; then swap to another seal and compare — that separates the melee chain from the ranged chain. If it genuinely does not trigger, add your seal, talents, and timing to the official thread; that carries more weight than a single post. Whether this gets fixed will show up in the next official hotfix list, and we will follow it here.